Steel Shingles Vs. Concrete Shingles

Benefits of Steel

• According to an article published in the "Sioux City Journal" online, many insurance companies offer discounts for customers who have steel roofs, due to their high quality and lower risk of damage. Shingles made out of steel resemble other products but are much more durable and long-lasting. Because steel is a metal, it is fireproof and wind-resistant. Products are available in a wide variety of colors and finishes, which makes steel a versatile option for both residential and commercial use.

Benefits of Concrete

• Although concrete can be used to make roof shingles, it is most commonly used as for roof tiles. As noted by This Old House, many homeowners who like the appearance of a tiled roof but can't afford clay tiles choose concrete tiles instead. Concrete tiles cost half as much as clay tiles and provide a similar appearance, which is particularly appropriate and common in the Southwest. Clay roofing materials are also very durable and fire-resistant. You can choose to keep the natural appearance of the concrete or use colored shingles.

Disadvantages of Steel

• The primary drawback of steel shingles is upfront cost. According to Homewyse.com's online calculator, a steel shingle roof costs approximately $5.05 per square foot, whereas a concrete tile roof only costs $3.99. Of course, specific costs vary based on your specific needs, but generally speaking, steel tends to be one of the most expensive roofing materials; however, most purchases come with a 50-year warranty, and steel is also more energy-efficient than many other roofing materials, which may save money on utility costs.

Disadvantages of Concrete

• Although concrete roofs are cheaper than steel, they are almost three times more expensive than asphalt, which is the most commonly used roofing material. As noted by This Old House, you should choose concrete shingles that have low porosity to prevent freeze damage. Concrete roofing porosity is usually rated from 3 to 20. Cement is also a very heavy roofing material, so installation and labor costs are more expensive than lighter products.